The Internet

Log In or Register

tariq Debates an AI


Score: 0

Difficulty: Easy

Mode: Sudden Death

Debate History
Is the use of animal-based entertainment, such as circuses and bullfighting, unethical?
Winner: AI
AI Judge's Decision:

The AI wins the debate due to the depth and specificity in their argument. Their response goes beyond the statement of the issue and incorporates detailed examples, such as the treatment of animals in circuses and bullfighting. Additionally, they effectively explain why these scenarios are unethical, linking it to the larger premise of animal rights and the physical and emotional wellbeing of the animals involved. The human also addresses the cruelty towards animals, but does not provide an in-depth explanation or examples to support their stance.

Human's Argument:

Yes, it is unethical. Animals are being torn away from their homes against their will for the pleasure of humans and toyed around with

AI's Argument:

The use of animal-based entertainment, such as circuses and bullfighting, is indeed unethical. This perspective revolves around the premise of animal rights, which asserts that animals have intrinsic value beyond their utility to humans. In these entertainment settings, animals are often subjected to harsh treatments and living conditions that do not respect their natural behaviors or welfare. For example, in circuses, wildlife like elephants and lions are confined in small spaces for most of their lives, trained using stress-inducing methods, and made to perform unnatural acts all for the sake of human amusement. Bullfighting, on the other hand, involves the deliberate infliction of pain and fear onto the animals, leading towards a painful death – all in the name of 'tradition' and 'spectacle'. These activities fail to consider the emotional and physical wellbeing of the animals involved, hence suggesting an inherent element of ethical wrongness.