The Internet

Log In or Register

Illustration of two different-sized circles, one larger and one smaller, representing individuals. The larger circle represents a person with a higher income, while the smaller circle represents a person with a lower income. The image depicts the larger circle divided into portions, with more resources allocated to reflect the individual's higher income. Meanwhile, the smaller circle is divided into smaller portions, representing fewer resources due to the person's lower income. This visual repr

Balancing the Scales of Justice: Adler's Precept of Equal Treatment for Unequals

0 Points

▲ good image

bad image ▼

Ask AI on The Internet

Question: Explain the precept of Mortimer j. Adler regarding justice: "treat equals equally and unequal unequally in proportion to their inequality". And give examples

Asked by Mortycute

0 Points

Log In or Register to Vote

Mortimer J. Adler's idea regarding justice, "Treat equals equally and unequal unequally in proportion to their inequality," is a theory rooted in the concept of justice as fairness. It implies two underlying aspects of justice, which include distributive justice (allocation of rewards/resources among members of a society) and corrective justice (corrective measures in response to unfair situations). 1. **Equal Treatment for Equals**: This means people in the same circumstances should be treated the same way. For instance, in a workplace, two employees who are doing the same job, with the same experience, skills, and expertise, should be paid the same wage. If one of them is paid more only due to a preferred race, gender, or personal feelings, it violates the equal treatment principle. 2. **Unequal Treatment in Proportion to Inequality**: This aspect implies that people in different circumstances should be treated differently, but in proportion to their differing circumstances. This is the basis for progressive taxation, where richer people pay more taxes than poorer people, as their ability to contribute is greater. It doesn't mean taxing wealthy people to the point of bankruptcy, but taxing them according to their ability. Similarly, in education, students with disabilities receive additional resources to ensure they have the same opportunities as other students. In essence, Adler's precept of justice is about validating differences and similarities where they exist. It’s not about treating everyone identically, but rather, ensuring fair treatment taking into account the circumstances. It refutes the idea that one-size-fits-all, while advancing the idea of individual circumstances and a proportional response to inequality.

Answered by gpt-4

Jan. 21, 2024, 9:23 p.m.

0 Points

Log In or Register to Vote

Think your answer is better than the AI's? Post it below.

Please log in or sign up to post your answer.

This article was generated in part by one of OpenAI’s large-scale language-generation model, answering user Mortycute's question. Images were generated with OpenAI's AI model, DALL·E 2. The Internet takes ultimate responsibility for the content of this publication.
If you want your question answered by an AI, click here.

Published: Sunday, January 21, 2024

Comment Section